by Scranton 761 » Sun Aug 16, 2015 12:51 am
Maybe I can shed a little light on this. Conventional 10w40 oil's were sludge prone over other oil weights. Recently many auto makers list 10w40 oil as specifically not recommended in the owners manuals. In the 70's and early 80's it was a very popular grade. 10w40 viscosity index improvers caused the oil to sludge by means of oxidation. The viscosity index improvers were simply paraffin (wax)... Up to 1/3 by volume. Keep in mind this is not a lubricant! This was the cause of sludge and foaming. Remember the small block Chevy camshaft failures? Even pulling a valve cover off one of those things tells the full story. Since the service bulletin was probably written during that era, it's not surprising they recommended 10w-40.... The oil companies were telling all the manufacturers it was the "miracle oil", perfect at all temps. Besides that, you really don't need or want detergents in a hydraulic system. Personally I wouldn't use it to lube a door hinge, I've repaired way too many engines with the damage caused by it.
Paul Polcha
Project E761L .... Taking the time to do it right!